Newsletter Signup | Subscribe to Magazine

Bourbon Recipes

Bold bourbons

Local restaurants and mixologists share details and recipes for their most prized creations.

Bourbon making can be traced back to the late 18th century, standing as a uniquely American spirit known for quality and craftsmanship. Because of specific and high standards, bourbon tastes different than other whiskeys such as Scotch, Irish, Canadian or Tennessee whiskey. There are many rules when it comes to bourbon, but just remember that all bourbons are whiskey, but not all whiskeys are bourbons. Smoother and more approachable than other whiskeys, bourbon has inherent flavors of vanilla, oak, fruit, spice and honey. This depth of flavor is subtle and complex but not overpowering, making bourbon easy to enjoy. The easily approachable taste can be enjoyed by connoisseurs and casual drinkers alike. Bourbon tastes magnificent straight up or on ice, but the depth of flavor makes for brilliant craft cocktails and classics, like the Manhattan and the Old Fashioned. Here are some cocktail recipes from local restaurants that use bourbon as their main ingredient.


Citrus Mint JulepELA’s On the Water 

Citrus Mint Julep

Ingredients 

2 ounces Anita’s Choice bourbon

3 slices of fresh orange 

3 dashes of orange bitters

Simple syrup

Splash of soda 

Sugar rim

Mint leaf garnish

Directions [1] Add bourbon, orange slices, orange bitters and simple syrup to a shaker, shake well and strain into a glass with a sugar rim. [2] Top with a splash of soda and garnish with mint or an orange slice.

“The Citrus Mint Julep is a new addition to our drink menu, but our take on a classic has quickly become a customer favorite.” — ELA’s On the Water


Michael Anthony’s Manhattan Michael Anthony’s Cucina Italiana 

Michael Anthony’s Manhattan 

Ingredients

1 1/2 ounces Old Forester 100

3/4 ounce Carpano sweet vermouth

2 dashes of Peychaud bitters

Fabbri Amarena cherry, for garnish

Directions [1] Combine the ingredients into a Yarai mixing glass filled halfway with ice. [2] Stir thoroughly. Strain into a rocks glass over an ice ball. [3] Garnish with an Amarena cherry. 

“Our guests love Elijah’s classic MA’s Manhattan because it is properly made with the best quality ingredients for a satisfyingly balanced Manhattan.” — Rebecca Fazzini, Michael Anthony’s Cucina Italiana


May River ManhattanThe Bluffton Room

May River Manhattan 

Ingredients 

2 ounces bourbon 

1/2 ounce dry vermouth 

1/2 ounce sweet vermouth 

1/2 ounce The Bluffton Room signature smoked cherry syrup

Grand Marnier and brandy-soaked Luxardo cherries for garnish

Orange peel for garnish

Slice of bacon for garnish 

Directions [1] Build in a mixing tin: layer bourbon, vermouths and cherry syrup. Gently tumble. [2] Transfer into a short cocktail glass and fill with ice. [3] Garnish with fresh orange peel, skewered cherries and a delicious slice of bacon.

“The May River Manhattan once won the B.O.B. award for Best Manhattan, and I think all of our guests still agree.” — Tonja Hughes, The Bluffton Room


Links Old Fashioned Links, an American Grill 

Links Old Fashioned 

Ingredients 

2 ounces Woodford Reserve

Small splash maple syrup

1/4 ounce simple syrup

3 dashes Bittermilk bitters

1 cinnamon stick

1 Bordeaux cherry

Nutmeg zest

Directions [1] Stir all ingredients in a glass. [2] Place a large ice cube in the glass and garnish with a cinnamon stick, Bordeaux cherry and nutmeg zest.

“Links’ signature Old Fashioned is a savory update on the classic cocktail that has both traditionalists and nouveau-seekers alike singing praises. Combining our own unique twist on bitters and syrup with The Sea Pines Resort’s own proprietary Barrel of Woodford Reserve Bourbon, this is a libation not to be missed.” — Links, an American Grill


Brooklyn Cocktail Callawassie Island

Brooklyn Cocktail 

Ingredients 

2 ounces Four Rose Single Barrel Bourbon

3/4 ounce Dolin Dry Vermouth

1/4 ounce China China

1/4 ounce Averna,

1/4 ounce Luxardo Maraschino Liqueur

2 dashes Angostura Bitters

Directions [1] In a 10-ounce rocks glass, stir all ingredients with a large rock. [2] Garnish with a Luxardo cherry.

“As former owner of The Lucky Rooster on Hilton Head Island, Chef Clayton Rollison was excited to introduce this cocktail to his new home at Callawassie Island. The Bourbon Society at Callaswassie Island was the first to enjoy this famous cocktail and now Callawassie
Island fan favorite!” 
— Callawassie Island


Blackberry Bourbon BrambleLong Cove Club 

Blackberry Bourbon Bramble

Ingredients 

2 blackberries

Several mint or basil leaves

2 ounces bourbon 

1/2 ounce Chambord 

1/2 ounce simple syrup

1/2 ounce fresh squeezed lemon juice

Ice 

Directions [1] Muddle together 1 blackberry and 3 mint or basil leaves. [2] Add bourbon, Chambord, simple syrup and lemon juice. [3] Shake together and double strain over ice. [4] Garnish with blackberry and basil or mint leaves.

“A large portion of our members are big bourbon fans, so we wanted to create something unique with fresh, tasty ingredients and a top-shelf bourbon.”— Long Cove Club


Earl Fashioned Colleton River Club 

Earl Fashioned 

Ingredients

1/4 slice of orange

3 Luxardo cherries

1 teaspoon Luxardo juice

Splash of simple syrup

A couple of drops of bitters

3 fingers of Woodford bourbon

Directions [1] Muddle all ingredients. [2] Add club soda and ice. 

“Our signature cocktail is inspired by one of our members, Earl, and is a favorite of the Colleton River members. Interesting facts about Earl: He has been with Colleton River Club for 12 years. Earl was born and raised on the Island, and his grandfather is 97 years old. Earl’s grandfather is the last Gullah man on Hilton Head Island.” — Colleton River Club


Kentucky Peach TeaOne Hot Mama’s 

Kentucky Peach Tea

Ingredients

1 1/2 ounces Evan Williams peach bourbon

Sweet tea

Directions [1] Fill a glass with ice and add bourbon. [2] Fill the rest with sweet tea. [3] Garnish with a lemon wedge. 

“Mouthwatering barbecue: Done. Casual, fun atmosphere: Got that. Refreshing, casual cocktail: Kentucky Peach Tea. One Hot Mamas Kentucky Peach Tea perfectly reflects the restaurant’s style; Southern, laid-back and delicious.” — One Hot Mama’s


Brooklyn Cocktail Old Town Dispensary 

Old Town Old Fashioned

Ingredients 

2 ounces Woodford Kentucky Bourbon 

1 orange slice 

1 Bordeaux cherry

1 ounce Bourbon maple syrup 

Directions [1] Muddle the cherry and orange in a glass. Add the bitters, syrup and bourbon. Top with ice. [2] Garnish with an orange wedge and a cherry. 

“This cocktail is named after our restaurant. The Old Fashion is a good classic drink, and we put our twist on it with the bourbon maple syrup.” — Old Town Dispensary