Chef cooking at a stove with other kitchen staff

What the Pros Love: Hilton Head Kitchen Superstitions

Every kitchen has its rituals. Some are rooted in family tradition, others in good luck and a few simply make the cook feel better before the first plate leaves the kitchen. We asked four Hilton Head chefs and restaurateurs about the superstitions they still follow, from tossing salt over a shoulder to exchanging a penny for a gifted knife.

We asked local chefs and restaurateurs their kitchen superstitions:

Chef’s knife beside a penny illustrating a family knife-gifting superstition

Palmetto Bay Sunrise Cafe

“In my family, if anyone ever gives someone else a knife, the receiver has to pay for it with a penny. It’s so the knife won’t sever the friendship between the giver and the receiver. It is a custom my father held with every knife he gave and is still carried on in our family.”

— Leslie Stewart


Bowl of Hoppin’ John on a red-and-white checked tablecloth

Hudson’s Seafood House on the Docks

“We eat collards and Hoppin’ John on New Year’s Day.”

— Andrew Carmines


Hand sprinkling salt against a dark background

Michael Anthony’s Cucina Italiana

“I toss a pinch of salt over my shoulder before service.”

— Chef Will Overacre


Chef cooking at a stove with other kitchen staff in the background

Cactus Street Cantina

“I don’t let people stand over me and watch me cook because I think the person’s energy can affect the outcome of the dish.”

— Chef Adolph Aguilar

Similar Posts